Kenneth Hite (princeofcairo) wrote,
Kenneth Hite

[Alternate Mondays] Bad Beat For Aaron Burr

I have a short story (only my second published one)1 in The New Hero, an upcoming anthology of iconic hero stories for Stone Skin Press.

My short story is called "Bad Beat For Aaron Burr," and its iconic hero, Ray Cazador, is essentially a skip-tracer who follows people to alternate Earths and brings them back alive. It's set in an alternate where Aaron Burr pulled the trigger on the 1806 plot, and in which that plot was not the detaching of the West as an independent country (which it most likely was) but an invasion of Mexico, which succeeded in this history because otherwise there wouldn't be much point in setting a story there. (British gold, Spanish fecklessness, criollo opportunism, if you're wondering how it might have worked.)

But one thing I didn't want to do was the standard "As you know, Bob" moment in which one character explains the alternate history to another character. It might have fit in an introductory scene, but I cut that scene because it slowed down the story. It certainly didn't fit in the story itself, nor could I have Ray Cazador look thoughtfully at a world map, read a historical novel, or do any of the other marginally-clever things alternate history fictioneers have their protagonists do so that the audience can get its uchronial rocks off.

Instead, I dropped little bits of the history into the story, hopefully causing a world to emerge from the tale in organic fashion. I only riff on the alternate itself when it specifically plays into my hero's tactical decisions on the ground; here's how Cazador explains how he knows where to find the fugitive, poker-fiend Troutman:

For example, a key rule for cross-world fugitives is: “Stay away from your past.” Not just your personal past – finding out what Mom is doing on this Earth is a great way to get rattled and get caught – but your Earth’s past. For some reason, runners stop and gawk at places that aren’t famous on their new Earth, wide spots in the Potomac marshes where the Lincoln Memorial should be, that kind of thing. On this Earth, France wouldn’t give a statue to the whipped-dog United States when it could kiss up to the Empire that Aaron Burr had built in Mexico. So this New York had a casino in the old fort on Bedloe’s Island, and Gustave Eiffel’s Statue of Fraternity stood in Veracruz harbor. But Troutman wouldn’t be in Veracruz, or anywhere else in El Imperio Mexicano. For one thing, Troutman didn’t speak any Spanish. Troutman’s politics probably ruled out the Confederacy, which was even poorer and more insular than this Earth’s United States anyway. It wasn’t impossible that Troutman had already gone north to Canada, cut a deal with the British. But not likely. In Troutman’s place, Cazador would want the security of “neutral ground” to negotiate any deal like that. And Troutman would need to get his legs under him in the new Earth. He’d be looking for something familiar and safe: poker.

As you know, Bob, Burr's Mexico must bend all its foreign policy energies to weakening and (ideally) fragmenting the United States, a program with definite European approval and assistance. Note the Confederacy, the "whipped-dog United States" (poor and insular; the story mentions New Dollars, a quarter with James G. Blaine's head on it, and puts a casino on the quondam Liberty Island) and the continued presence of the British in Canada. Later on (as Cazador attempts to figure out a foe's accent) I imply that Cuba and Guatemala are provinces of Imperial Mexico, neither one much of a stretch.

I remain tricksy about whether the alternate-world travel includes time-travel; whether the alternate worlds have "alternate presents" too. (Technology is meant to sound slightly retrograde, but not utterly primitive.) Mostly because the story doesn't need me to mention it. If I were to write a whole bunch of Ray Cazador stories, I'd probably have to have one that turns on that point, or more likely just explain it in an introduction. Which I'd probably call "As You Know, Bob."

As you know, Bob, Burr's conspiracy included a number of young, ambitious frontiersmen such as Andrew Jackson and Sam Houston. Just as in our timeline, they prospered when given ridiculous amounts of executive and military authority. The antagonist's name is: "Don Vicente Teodoro Garcia Estancia y Jackson. Mexican near-royalty then. Then Cazador read the printing above the name: Ministeria Confidential de la Emperador. Don Vicente was near royalty in more ways than his blood: he worked for the Confidential Ministry of His Imperial Majesty Aaron IV Burr."

Later on, we speculate about how to get out of New York:

Extracting Troutman by train would take too long: hours to get to Colorado and the Imperial border. Hours in which anything could go wrong, including another border crossing into the nervous, touchy Columbian Union at Youngstown. A car or truck had the same problems, compounded by the grim prospect of an undignified road trip across a parochial, backward countryside full of people who sullenly resented Imperial Mexico.

A successful Burr Conspiracy isn't going to defuse Midwestern secessionist spirit. Rather the opposite. I suspect the Columbian Union separates during the Civil War (which might well have come earlier, with no Mexican War to offer the South hope for expanding slavery) or perhaps during whichever war it is that inflates the U.S. economy enough to demand "New Dollars."

And one last bit, a list of plausible Great Powers:

As the guards fell in behind them, Cazador turned to Don Vicente. Now was the time to damp that frustration, to give him what he wanted: an explanation. In a conversational tone, Cazador said “Moscow.” France and Britain too easy to check, Japan too outré. The Russians seemed like the right touch.

Defeat in the Napoleonic Wars isn't going to end Britain; Japan's rise makes sense regardless; Russia remaining a Great Power likewise.

And one or two things I just threw in for alternates' sake: New York accents are "more Irish-Italian-Breton than Jewish-Italian in this world." That's because I assumed a victorious Bonapartist-Republican France begins encouraging the monarchist Bretons to emigrate. I never did explain why the Jews don't go to America en masse (although I do have one Jewish character in the story's New York); probably the independent Polish Republic/Kingdom of Poland (depending on exactly how Vienna goes in this world) makes the intelligent decision that its most literate, productive citizens should stay there and improve the tax base.

There's a couple more bits of that history in the story, but that should be enough to get everyone started.

1) The first was "Ring Around the Sun," the introductory fiction for Secrets of the Ruined Temple.
Tags: alternate history, america, fiction, the new hero
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.


March 8 2011, 03:22:17 UTC 8 years ago

After reading "For Want of a Nail" I can't get enough of American-Mexican fusion empires. And there is simply not enough alternatehistory material about Old Northwest/Ohio Territory secession.

An early Washington death, the Continental Army vets marching into Ohio to carve out their own country, no Washington to give proto-federalists any legitimacy with the South - the United States collapses over the Constitutional Convention. Adams' New England and Jefferson's South are as friendly as can be given the circumstances, but tension with radical Democratic-Republican conspirators in New York could cause a cold war under the icy grip of the Hamilton regime - and in isolation the South slides into wealthy stagnation and decadence under slaveocrats. The kind of frontier-loving people like Jackson who revitalized populistic Democratic politics would either go to Ohio and filibuster to create their own countries, Southwest Conspiracy style, given the fractious nature of the settled East. This leaves Eastern politics in the grips of High Federalists and a pale shell of the Democratic-Republican party after Jefferson's death that is more like the Southern Tory-leaners hesitant to get into the revolution in the first place.

Without Jeffersonian radicalism, the South would certainly not mind allying with Britain but the rise of anti-slavery patrols and the like in British politics would probably result in a gradual weaning off the Anglo-relations, as the "support both against each other" strategy eventually morphs into "make New England dependent on us", while the South perhaps attaches it's star to the slowly decaying Spanish Empire.

Whoo, tangent.

Back to the subject of Burr! I have the image that the modern Mexican Empire would have the Imperial Guard or palace guards or otherwise the Emperor's regiment be the Cherokee Guard or something to that effect; though to be honest I've never really read much historical matter about Burr and Native Americans, it's just mentioned in the Suppressed Transmission article "Alternity Duels".

Though in terms of a Mexican Empire, a Native American detachment from the Southwest Our-Timeline-US, rather than the Mayas of the Yucatan, would probably be suitably menacing and awe-inspiring yet disconnected with internal issues of the nation at large.
The story implies that the Pawnee, at least, control or have free use of the land north of the Red River. In my own notions, Burr's Mexican Empire winds up with a number of such marcher nations: Comancheria, Apacheria, etc.
This is a story that not only fulfills the iconic hero brief, but avoids all of the pitfalls of the alternative history sub-genre.
I hope it helps, but the Spanish printing would most likely say:

Ministerio Confidencial del Imperador.

Just trying to help.


a tale of Joe McCarthy vs. Will Rogers.
Seems like a well-done story; avoiding "as you know, Bob" is really hard to do (I've tried to write AH stories myself, and know).

The only problem I have with it is the image of Aaron Burr as a would-be Napoleon. Every AH I've read that involves Burr paints him that way, but let's not forget that this was the standard accusation in political smear campaigns.

(This is actually the classic post-revolutionary pattern; factions develop and immediately start accusing each other of trying to re-establish the "old ways," which in America would of course be dynastic monarchy.)

I did a fair amount of research on Burr in college, and everything I found tells me that, if he really was involved in a separatist revolution, it would have been to try to establish a new republic; one that would avoid the "errors" he perceived being made by the Jefferson administration.

I'd love to see an AH in which a successful Burr Conspiracy created a federation or something. It would sure be a breath of fresh air.

BTW, talking about post-revolutionary situations gave me the idea of a world where the Nazis conquered Europe and America, then were overthrown in a revolution -- and then everyone accuses each other of trying to start the Fourth Reich.
I agree with you that Burr gets something of an unfair rap in general, and is unfairly neglected for his key role in thwarting Jefferson's attempt to purge the judiciary.

That said, if he conquered Mexico, he surely wouldn't institute a republic. Note that Bolivar, for example, became a dictator despite faultlessly republican ideology to begin with; and Bonapartism was in the air in 1806.
Yum, yum...
For an avid alternate-histories plus Burr admirer (blame on G. Vidal!) as myself, the whole settign sounds astounding... Thanks a bunch!
But, may I be so bold as to digress a bit? Because since I got word of the whole Toynbee-Hite "Midgard" alternate setting, I have been longing for such a possibility. Any hope for this alternate-ravenous Basque/Viking???
Yups, I forgot:
"Ministeria Confidential de la Emperador". In correct Spanish it should be "Ministerio Confidencial del Emperador".