Having hit a momentary gap in the onslaught that is
Trail of Cthulhu, it's time to post my post-Chicago International Film Festival roundup, as always using the format and judgement categories of
robin_d_laws'
Toronto roundup post.I am willing to take some of the blame for this year's less than superb experience -- when you're spending damn near every waking moment either at a movie theater or writing RPG rules, you lose a certain detachment that might be needed to fully accept that foreign directors have their own notions of narrative and color and so forth. My mom's visit meant I had to jam everything into ten days instead of 15, and so we missed some likely contenders, and I missed
Antenna, which
gnosticpi and
his_regard said was Recommended, at least. And when you're watching some large chunk of the films gooned on DayQuil to keep your head cold at bay, you may miss a few stray strands of brilliance. Between one thing and another, we skipped
All the Invisible Things to take a needed sleep-in day, and our showing of
Not By Chance was cancelled. And as it happened, I only saw one film that made the dozen "Best of the Fest," so perhaps we just picked badly to begin with.
That said, this was by fairly universal assessment a mediocre Film Fest year. Way too many films that will inevitably show up in general release, way too many American movies, and what -- only
one South Korean film? Did the great gold-farming republic fall down on the job of cinema last year, or did the Festival committee recoil from the Korean onslaught last year? The international side was not just small but fairly weak in general; Takashi Miike's new Western was especially missed, but genre always takes a boot to the head at this show, which even in its best years still has a strong middlebrow tendency.
But even its somewhat-best years are better than this one. Or maybe it's the DayQuil talking.
The BestEye in the Sky (Yau Nai Hoi, HK) I'm surprised there isn't already a law against thrillers this good, enforced by the vast majority of directors and producers. In control, feel, and good old-fashioned nail-biting suspense, this tale of an elite jewel theft gang and an equally-elite Hong Kong police surveillance unit just can't be topped. It seamlessly delivers character, setting, and narrative with beautiful efficiency. It's almost on a par with
The Departed, and easily the equal of the
Bourne movies. It leaves virtually everything else you've seen in the genre looking kind of sad. Johnnie To was a producer on it, and it shows.
Becky Sharp (Rouben Mamoulian, USA (1935)) Meanwhile, Rouben Mamoulian and William Makepeace Thackeray between them refute any notion of progress since 1935 or 1847. Both the movie and the novel (
Vanity Fair, for those just joining us) conclusively demonstrate that everything modernism claims to have accomplished was already present and alive before it got started in film and literature, respectively. Miriam Hopkins heads a sure-fire cast (Nigel Bruce is especially delightful as Joseph Sedley, as is Cedric Hardwicke as the depraved Marquis of Steyne), and the script (from a play based on the novel) horsewhips Mira Nair's crap 2004 version up and down the street. This was the first feature shot in three-strip Technicolor, and the restored version just glows -- the production design is wonderfully alien to our modernist sensibilities, and looks like a million bucks.
OSS 117: Cairo, Nest of Spies (Michael Hazanavicius, France) Where this amiable romp truly stands out is Jean Dujardin as the titular OSS 117 -- he can go from Sean Connery to Will Ferrell and back again in a split second, giving a beautiful performance as an idiot manchild who happens to be postwar France's top spy in Nasser's Cairo. It's a better conceit than Austin Powers, since "Hubert Bonnisseur de la Bath" is actually as sexy and tough as he thinks he is -- he's just also an idiot with a four-second attention span. (The parallels with the West in general -- sexy, tough, self-absorbed, and stupid -- are not hammered home, but are quite intentional.) Special kudos also to the costumes, which effortlessly replicate classic-period Bond. This is the one of my choices that made "Best of the Fest," btw.
RecommendedHard-Hearted (Aleksei Mizgiryov, Russia) To its
Training Day: Moscow vibe, this surprisingly deep urban drama adds the "hero comes West" archetype and a love story by turns touching, desperate, and scary. Moscow comes alive as a setting, though mostly through the characters and the types they represent.
You, the Living (Roy Andsersson, Swe-Ger-Fra-Den-Nwy) Basically a series of sharp vignettes best summed up as "Ingmar Bergman's Monty Python's
Meaning of Life." Each shot, however, is framed and set up with creepily exact Scandinavian precision; it's an abstract mosaic of brilliantly polished gems.
Trade Routes (Jim Loftus, Bulgaria/USA) More than adequate Le Carre-style post-Cold War thriller about the intersection of a junior CIA agent, an ambitious democratic Bulgarian politician, his American campaign manager, and a nervous Bulgarian state security chief. The plot is the highlight, with the whole thing ticking down like Greek tragedy -- you know what's coming, and you can't wait to find out. The wild cards are a retired Bulgarian spy, his mafiya pal, and the creepy nationalist Front movement. The Bulgarians in the audience were full of sputtered Balkan objections, which filled me with the urge to go to a Bulgarian film festival, attend a movie set in Chicago, and spend the entire Q&A session arguing with the director about the decor of Mister Beef.
GoodControl (Anton Corbijn, USA) If you're a big Joy Division fan, this is "Recommended" on the basis of the soundtrack (and the incidental score by New Order), but it never exceeds the biopic straitjacket. The tone is nicely north-of-England staid and undramatic, which on the one hand evokes Macclesfield well, but on the other doesn't really let us into the movie. We watch Ian Curtis live, write, marry, sing, cheat, and despair by the numbers, and only a few voiceovers try to tell us why any of it happens. Sam Riley does what he can with the part, but the real fun is Craig Parkinson's Tony Wilson.
Weirdsville (Allan Moyle, USA/Canada) Slacker drug comedies, like teen romance comedies, run to a formula. This one does, too, although there are a whole carload of midgets instead of just one, and the blonde Satanist with the machete livens things up a bit. Matt Frewer is in it, along with a lot of people you wouldn't flip on cable to watch -- Scott Speedman, Wes Bentley, Taryn Manning -- unless you were already stoned. That said, you'd leave it on, even if you were out of Cheetos.
OkayBeaufort (Joseph Cedar, Israel) This one might have vaulted up to "Good" if I hadn't been previously irritated at
Session 9 for likewise wasting a superior concept -- the IDF, harassed by Hezbollah, waits to evacuate a mountaintop outpost -- and a wonderful set -- a recreation of the Crusader castle Beaufort -- on a rote iteration of a formulaic story. The dramatic high point occurs in the first ten minutes, and the movie spends another two hours, in "Itchy & Scratchy" terms, driving slowly away from the firework factory. It turns out that occupying Lebanon is pointless. Go figure. If you're grading on a curve, this could go up to "Good" merely for depicting soldiers accurately, but that should be like keeping the lens cap off, or using the boom mike correctly -- the baseline of acceptability, not a cause for special commendation, especially in a war film.
Almost GoodSurveillance (Paul Oremland, UK) It's rare to wish a film looked worse, but this one needed to. The conceit is that the whole thing is assembled from surveillance-camera, CCTV, and phone-cam footage, but it doesn't remotely look like it, being shot in bright digital video for the most part. The script has way too many interiors -- the whole thing should have been set in seemingly deserted outside locations, or eerily miked in crowds. Walter Murch could have saved this film; the director admitted that it was a rewrite short of what he wanted to see. The story is stupid, but even good conspiracy films never care that much about such things -- it's the production design and locations that needed changing.
Not GoodDuchess of Langeais (Jacques Rivette, France/Italy) I don't know, but I wouldn't be surprised to learn that everyone involved in this movie lost a World Cup bet or something, and were forced to make a film based on this Balzac novel as a consequence. Nobody -- not the director, the actors, the producer, the writer -- seems to know or care why they're there. It has a certain level of competence, and individual scenes are sometimes well-acted, but it's like Rivette just filmed until he ran out of pages and celluloid and went home.
Opium: Diary of a Madwoman (Janos Szasz, Hungary) We disputed afterwards whether this was a hackneyed story told sententiously or a mawkish story told predictably. Nothing in it remotely surprised anyone, probably including the characters themselves, which is a shame when you're in a Hungarian insane asylum in 1913. By about halfway through, I was entertaining myself imagining future archaeologists assembling the entire conventional narrative and ideological context of 20th century feminism from this film alone, although the frequent naked breasts might confuse them.
Actively HorribleHeartbeat Detector (Nicolas Klotz, France) Who knew it was possible to make a film that simultaneously trivializes, and lugubriously pontificates on, the Holocaust? (Okay, Roberto Benigni knew.) Perhaps this works in France, but -- SPOILER ALERT! -- "European executives had connections with the Holocaust" is not exactly the Big Reveal in my neck of the woods in this year 62 A.P. (After Patton). When you don't care about the characters, there's no point in showing endless footage of their slack-jawed reaction to something a schoolchild can find out on Wikipedia. The whole "conspiracy" is nothing more than tedious corporate politics -- lots of arbitrary footage hints at a story the filmmakers are too chicken to write. A tiresome, cowardly, sententious waste of good actors and everyone's time, most especially mine.